Summer Pot Luck Selection: The Spellman Files by Lisa Lutz

All three of the Holmes Public Library book clubs will come together in one big group on Tuesday, August 18, at 6 p.m. to share a pot luck supper and talk about The Spellman Files by Lisa Lutz, a fun summer read. Hope you can make it!

What We Thought: Falling Angels by Tracy Chevalier

Falling Angels

by Tracy Chevalier

“When daddy saw the angel on the grave next to ours, he cried, 'What the devil!'"
-- from Falling Angels, when Maude Coleman saw the marker on the family plot of where Lavinia and Ivy May Waterhouse were standing.

Readers compared Falling Angels to The Age of Desire, a previous book club selection by Jennie Fields. They were interested in the descriptions of life in Victorian England on the cusp of the Edwardian era, but felt they were not detailed enough to satisfy interest in historical fiction. Some were disappointed in the author’s treatment of the characters. They expected a book more like Girl with the Pearl Earring. A few readers said that based on their experience with Falling Angels they would not care to read any more of Chevalier’s works. Others said that they enjoyed her books and plan to read more of them. The majority of the group was not enthusiastic about this month’s selection.

Although the behavior of the characters was typical of the time period, the discussion centered on why they acted the way they did. People are a product of their times and some are rebellious and some go along with the status quo. The majority of the discussion was about funerals, burial customs then and now, cremation and urn design. The beginning of the suffragette and women’s rights movement was briefly discussed and then the group moved on to dissect the marriages of Kitty and Gertrude Waterhouse and how their personalities influenced relationships with their husbands and each other. The supporting characters of the grave digger’s child, Simon, and Jenny, the maid, interested them more than the wealthy women and their husbands.

One reader summed up the book saying it was about children playing in a cemetery, suffragettes, and dying. The book is dark and brooding and, some said, very British, even though the author is an American. There was talk about the significance of falling angels in the title. The children said that they believed that shooting stars were angels carrying messages to the living. Readers agreed that the broken angel grave monument was proof of mortality, and then there was more talk about cremation. 

Please join the discussion by using the comments section below!